Tonner Doll Company, Inc. ~ Robert Tonner Collectibles, 18" Vinyl Dolls


About Just Magic
Meet the Dolls
Pictures and Stories
Message Boards
Contact the Webmaster


The three Tonner Collectibles. Click

for a larger image.



14" Betsy McCall on the left and 18" Baking Gingerbread on the right. Notice any resemblance? Click picture for a close-up.

Doll Line

Robert Tonner Collectibles






Tonner Doll Company, Inc.


Robert Tonner

Production Years



Height 19", Chest 6 1/2", Hips 6 1/4", Waist 10", Wig size 11 1/2, Foot 65 mm

Body Type

All vinyl, strung arms, flange jointed legs


Inset acrylic, fixed  


Kanekalon wig 

Identifying Markings

"Robert Tonner, 2002" on back of neck, "Penny" in small letters on top of limbs. 

Retail Price

$99.99 (Baking Gingerbread) -  $124.99



Clothing Fit

Same body as 18" Ann Estelle, Penney and Friends and Linda Rick Lovee/Key to My Heart, so their clothes fit perfectly. Similar in size to Magic Attic, Stardust Classics, Just Pretend and Carpatina, so their clothes fit fairly well (Collectibles' waist and chest is slightly larger). MAC-size shoes fit perfectly. American Girl clothes and shoes are generally too big.

Dolls in Series

Alice, Baking Gingerbread and Red Riding Hood




These were only produced for one year and are hard to find. The secondary market is your best source.

For More Information

The AnnieFan group on YahooGroups (which is primarily devoted to 18" Ann Estelle) is a great place to meet other collectors of these dolls.


These three 18" vinyl dolls are part of the Robert Tonner Collectibles line from 2002 which also included three large, soft-body Boudoir dolls which have nothing else in common with the child dolls. On the doll collecting lists, we sometimes refer to these as the "Don't Call Me Betsy" dolls because they have the same face and outfits as the 14" Betsy McCall dolls (such as this 14" Betsy as Red Riding Hood) though they are not part of that line. Reportedly, this is because Tonner failed to obtain the licensing rights from the new owners of "McCall's" magazine. Still, this 18" doll comes from a long line of wonderful dolls inspired by the paperdoll drawings (first published in 1951 in McCall's magazine) by Kay Morrissey. Joanie Dawson's Betsy McCall Grows Up With Us webpage has pictures of the different dolls, starting from the first in 1952 up to the 14" Tonner version introduced in 1997.

Regardless of what these are called, these are wonderful 18" child dolls! They are very, very similar to the 18" Ann Estelle dolls that debuted a year before the Collectibles. They share the same body, as do the Penney and Friends dolls that Tonner created for J.C. Penney and the Linda Rick Lovee/Key to My Heart dolls which are more recent. The face sculpt is different from Ann Estelle but the construction is similar and of equal, high quality. Like the Ann Estelle doll, they are marketed as 18", but they are actually 19" as you can see in the pictures below which compare the body type to an 18" Magic Attic doll.

Like the Magic Attic dolls (also sculpted by Tonner), these dolls are slimmer than American Girl dolls and have smaller feet. The Collectibles didn't have separate outfits available, but they can fit the 18" Ann Estelle clothing and most Magic Attic-size outfits and shoes.

You can see a scan of the Collectibles page from the 2002 catalog at the Tonner website catalog archive (click your browser's Back button to return here):

Robert Tonner Collectibles catalog page

Tonner Doll Company logo and Robert Tonner Collectibles are Copyright Tonner Doll Company, Inc.

Special thanks to Gigi for her pics of Big Betsy and Little Betsy Baking Gingerbread

Copyright 2005 Maria Greene All Rights Reserved

Home • About Just Magic • Meet the Dolls • Articles • Pictures and Stories • Message Boards • Links • Contact the Webmaster

This page was last updated 07/24/07